The Chosen of Shar is a major companion quest in Baldur's Gate 3 that centers directly around Shadowheart's devotion to the Nightsinger. Navigating this storyline requires players to explore ancient ruins, solve intricate trials, and face heavy narrative decisions. The outcomes of this quest shape Shadowheart's fate and permanently alter the broader world state.
Beginning the Shadowheart Questline
Players can unlock this storyline early in Act 1 by discussing Shadowheart's religious beliefs and her goal of becoming a Dark Justiciar. Interacting with Sharran artifacts, inspecting murals in the Emerald Grove, and exploring the Grymforge helps advance her personal dialogue. Keeping her in your active party during these moments builds essential rapport for future choices.
Navigating the Gauntlet of Shar
The quest reaches its primary turning point inside the Gauntlet of Shar hidden deep within the Shadow-Cursed Lands. To proceed, party members must collect Umbral Gems by completing various trials testing stealth and tactical combat. Players must also retrieve the Spear of Night from the Silent Library to complete the required ritual.
Crucial Choices in the Shadowfell
Upon descending into the Shadowfell, players encounter Balthazar and the imprisoned Dame Aylin, also known as the Nightsong. You can choose to support Shadowheart in slaying the Nightsong, or attempt a persuasive check to convince her to spare the immortal entity. Allowing Balthazar to claim the Nightsong will result in Shadowheart permanently abandoning the party.
Long-Term Consequences and Story Impact
Slaying the Nightsong grants Shadowheart powerful gear and fully commits her to the goddess Shar. However, this choice causes the protective barrier at Last Light Inn to fall, leading to the deaths of several key allies. Sparing Dame Aylin leads Shadowheart toward the light of Selûne, opening new story paths in Act 3.